9-11 & 13-25 Railroad Avenue

Middletown, NY

Land for Sale - $3,300,000 - 29,024 Sq. Ft. on 1.67 acres


Agent Info

Robert Quinn

Property Info

CIMLS#1196966
Location
  9-11 & 13-25 Railroad Avenue
  Middletown NY 10940
UpdatedOctober 25th, 2026
TypeLand
Price$3,300,000
Building29,024 Sq. Ft.
Land1.67 acres

Attached Documents


Property Description

A rare downtown assemblage with long-term redevelopment potential. The offering combines two contiguous tax lots at 9-11 and 13-25 Railroad Avenue (26-1-11.1 and 26-1-13), totaling 1.67 acres, with 371 feet of frontage on Railroad Avenue and 140 feet on Grove Street. The site is generally level, served by municipal water, sewer and gas, and located outside the flood zone (Zone X).

The existing 29,024 SF commercial building is occupied by a single tenant under a NNN lease that runs through May 31, 2030. That lease provides in-place occupancy while a buyer plans and pursues approvals. The site also has a large paved parking area. Rooftop solar array in place; details available to qualified buyers.

The property is zoned DMU Downtown Mixed Use, which generally calls for ground-floor commercial space with residential above. It offers potential for up to six stories within a 90-foot height limit, subject to municipal approvals. The site sits steps from the Short Line bus terminal at 14 Railroad Avenue, which offers daily commuter service to New York City, and is located in an Opportunity Zone.

The property suits an owner-user, adaptive reuse, or phased mixed-use redevelopment. Lease terms and due diligence materials are available to qualified buyers after a confidentiality agreement is signed. Asking price: $3,300,000.


Financials

Asking price: $3,300,000. Sale-leaseback: the building is occupied by a single tenant under a NNN lease that runs through May 31, 2030. No cap rate is advertised. Lease terms and due diligence materials are available to qualified buyers after a confidentiality agreement is signed.